Verse 8: How can I know that the Unmanifest, which I cannot perceive, really exists?

saukṣmyāt-tat-anupalabdhiḥ nā-abhāvāt kāryataḥ tat-upalabdheḥ |
mahat-ādi tat-ca kāryaṃ prakṛtisarūpaṃ virūpaṃ ca ||

sūkṣma – subtle
anupalabdhiḥ – non-perception
kāryatas – through its effects
upalabdhi – perception

Relying on causality, I Infer it from its effects.

  1. Having acknowledged the limitations of my own senses (verse 7), I acknowledge that not being able to perceive a thing does not necessarily mean it does not exist.
  2. And so I allow that not being able to perceive the Unmanifest (Prakrti) does not mean that it does not exist.
  3. I can perceive Intelligence (Mahat) and everything that the Unmanifest (Prakrti) causes.
  4. I can infer (verse 6) that therefore there must be something that causes Intelligence (Mahat).
  5. I identify the Unmanifest (Prakrti) as that which causes Intelligence (Mahat).
  6. I acknowledge that there are things that are too subtle for me to perceive (verse 7).
  7. And so I acknowledge that the Unmanifest (Prakrti) may also be too subtle for me to perceive.
  8. In my attempt to infer what the Unmanifest (Prakrti) is, I acknowledge that like a son is similar to and different from his father, so the effects of the Unmanifest are both similar to and different from it.
  1. There is a field of darkness through which I cannot perceive.
  2. There is a field of inference (also dark, but not AS dark) into which I can infer
  3. There is a field of light in which I can perceive.
  4. In the darkness is a shape I can hardly make out.
  5. In the inferred darkness there are shapes that have in them the shape that is in darkness.
  6. In the light are shapes that have in them the shapes that are inferred.
  7. In the light are shapes that have in them other shapes from the light … their relationship reveals inference.
  8. With inference in the field of light I can infer the things in the darker inferred field.
  9. From those things (and with inference from the light) I can infer subtle nature that is in the field of darkness.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *